Refrigerator filter shopping starts with one important split: are you replacing an air filter that addresses refrigerator odors, or a water filter made for a specific refrigerator filter number? The packs below serve different jobs, so the right choice is driven by the filter location and compatible model language-not pack count alone.
Quick take
For an air-filter replacement, the Refrigerator Air Filter Replacement 4 Pack, Carbon Activated Filter Compatibl is the lowest-listed-price choice at $9.62 and is described for Frigidaire and Electrolux Pure Air Ultra, EAFCBF, PAULTRA, and RAF1150 references. The 6 Pack Refrigerator Air Filter Replacement for FRGPAAF2 Frigidaire PureAir AF provides two more filters and is tailored to FRGPAAF2 / PureAir AF-2 compatibility.
For a water-filter replacement, the decision is model-specific. The 4 PACK ΕVΕRYDROP ΕDR2RXD1 Refrigerator Wate Filter 2 Replacement Home NEW US is the four-item EveryDrop 2 / EDR2RXD1 option for Whirlpool compatibility. The 6 pack Refrigerator water filter Replacement for KAD3RXD1,WHR3RXD1,W101211416 has the largest water-filter pack and names KAD3RXD1, WHR3RXD1, and W101211416 among its compatible model references.
Listed price comparison
| Filter option | Type and pack | Listed price | Relative price bar |
|---|---|---|---|
| Refrigerator Air Filter Replacement 4 Pack, Carbon Activated Filter Compatibl | Air filter, 4 pack | $9.62 | |
| 6 Pack Refrigerator Air Filter Replacement for FRGPAAF2 Frigidaire PureAir AF | Air filter, 6 pack | $11.18 | |
| 6 pack Refrigerator water filter Replacement for KAD3RXD1,WHR3RXD1,W101211416 | Water filter, 6 pack | $22.49 | |
| 4 PACK ΕVΕRYDROP ΕDR2RXD1 Refrigerator Wate Filter 2 Replacement Home NEW US | Water filter, 4 pack | $43.99 |
The listed range runs from $9.62 to $43.99. That range reflects two different filter categories as well as different pack counts, so it is more useful to compare air filters against air filters and water filters against water filters.
Decision matrix
- Need a Frigidaire PureAir AF-2 / FRGPAAF2 air filter: Start with the Dicheny six-pack when that exact replacement family matches your refrigerator.
- Need a Frigidaire or Electrolux air filter tied to PAULTRA, EAFCBF, or RAF1150: The YANENAN four-pack directly names those references.
- Need an EveryDrop 2 / EDR2RXD1 water filter for a Whirlpool-compatible refrigerator: Choose the EveryDrop four-pack.
- Need a water filter associated with KAD3RXD1, WHR3RXD1, or W101211416: The six-pack replacement is the relevant match.
Product notes
6 Pack Refrigerator Air Filter Replacement for FRGPAAF2 Frigidaire PureAir AF
Choose this Dicheny air-filter pack when FRGPAAF2 or PureAir AF-2 is the replacement reference associated with your refrigerator. Its six-filter count is larger than the other air-filter pack, and the description names a long group of Frigidaire refrigerator models, including FRFC2323AS, FRFS2823AS, and GRFS2853AF. It uses coconut-shell activated carbon and pleated construction, with no-tools installation described. The trade-off is fit specificity: this is an air-filter replacement centered on the FRGPAAF2 / PureAir AF-2 family, rather than a water-filter option. At $11.18, it sits close to the lower end of the overall price range.
Refrigerator Air Filter Replacement 4 Pack, Carbon Activated Filter Compatibl
At $9.62, this YANENAN four-pack is the lowest-listed-price option in the comparison and a focused choice for refrigerator air-filter replacements associated with Frigidaire and Electrolux. The named references include Pure Air Ultra, EAFCBF, PAULTRA, RAF1150, SCPUREAIR2PK, and PS1993820. Carbon fiber is listed as the material, while the description describes activated carbon intended to absorb food odors and excess moisture; it also recommends changing the air filter every six months. Its limitation is simple: the pack contains four filters, while the FRGPAAF2-oriented Dicheny air-filter option contains six. It is an odor-focused refrigerator air filter, not a water filter.
4 PACK ΕVΕRYDROP ΕDR2RXD1 Refrigerator Wate Filter 2 Replacement Home NEW US
This EveryDrop option makes sense when the needed water-filter reference is EveryDrop 2 or EDR2RXD1 and the refrigerator is Whirlpool-compatible. The title and model information align around that specific replacement identity, and the set contains four white filters with charcoal listed as the material. It is the most expensive listed option at $43.99, which is the key limitation for shoppers deciding among the four packs. It also has fewer items than the six-pack water-filter alternative, though they are made for different compatibility references. Select it for the EDR2RXD1 match rather than treating it as an interchangeable choice for KAD3RXD1 or WHR3RXD1 replacements.
6 pack Refrigerator water filter Replacement for KAD3RXD1,WHR3RXD1,W101211416
Pick this six-pack water-filter replacement when KAD3RXD1, WHR3RXD1, W101211416, W10177635, or W1018666 appears in the required replacement references. At $22.49, it is the lower-listed-price water-filter choice here and includes two more filters than the EveryDrop EDR2RXD1 pack. Carbon/charcoal filtration is listed, along with chlorine taste and odor contaminant removal; the description also describes a coconut-shell carbon block and tool-free installation. The limitation is that it is not positioned as an EDR2RXD1 / EveryDrop 2 replacement. Its value comes from the six-filter format only after the named KAD3RXD1, WHR3RXD1, or W101211416 compatibility wording matches your need.
Final recommendation by use case
Choose the YANENAN Refrigerator Air Filter Replacement 4 Pack for the lowest listed price among the four options and Frigidaire/Electrolux air-filter references such as PAULTRA or RAF1150. Choose the Dicheny 6 Pack Refrigerator Air Filter Replacement if FRGPAAF2 / PureAir AF-2 is the needed air-filter family and six filters suit your replacement cycle.
For water filtration, choose the EveryDrop EDR2RXD1 four-pack only for the EveryDrop 2 / Whirlpool-compatible match. Choose the six-pack KAD3RXD1, WHR3RXD1, W101211416 replacement when those specific water-filter references are the target and a six-pack is preferable.
