When a range hood stops responding or a grill won't spark, you need a replacement part that matches the appliance in front of you. These two repairs are entirely different: one restores ignition to many Sam's Club grills, and the other replaces the control panel on a traditional range hood. The Modern Home Products Replacement Ignitor MHP IG-17B and the Range Hood Switch 5 Button Universal Switch CW1 each solve one of those problems, so the right choice depends on which appliance is broken.
Quick Verdict
If your Sam's Club grill uses multiple cast iron or brass burners and the ignition has failed, the MHP IG-17B igniter is the part to order. If your range hood has a traditional pushbutton panel that needs replacing, the Range Hood Switch is the right fit.
Price and Fit at a Glance
| Feature | MHP IG-17B Ignitor | Range Hood Switch |
| Price | $15.97 | $13.19 |
| Function | Replacement igniter component | Universal pushbutton control board |
| Fits | Many Sam's Club grills with cast iron or brass burners | Traditional range hood extractor fans with five key switches |
| Build | New sealed unit | PP plastic with built-in/integrated installation |
Where Each Product Wins
- The MHP igniter wins when you need a straight replacement for a Sam's Club grill ignition system, especially with multiple cast iron or brass burners. Its model listing points to Sam's Club Member's Mark IG17B compatibility.
- The Range Hood Switch wins for typical range hoods and for the lower price on the page. It also offers a universal fit rather than a grill-specific part.
Product Notes
Modern Home Products Replacement Ignitor Component MHP IG-17B
This replacement igniter is aimed at Sam's Club grill owners whose ignition has stopped working with multiple cast iron or brass burners. It arrives as a new, sealed unit and references the Sam's Club Member's Mark IG17B model. If your grill matches that burner setup, this component could be the direct fix you need. Keep in mind that the packaging says to check your grill for accurate fit before purchase, so confirm your specific model's burner layout first. This is a component for the ignition system, not a full grill replacement.
Range Hood Switch 5 Button Universal Switch CW1
This universal switch is designed for traditional range hoods with a five-button layout. It's made from PP plastic and installs as a built-in/integrated control board, making it a straightforward swap for a worn panel. The package includes one key switch with a compact board length of about 12cm and a cord of roughly 40cm. That smaller footprint is helpful for tight hood designs, but it also means you should verify the existing opening and switch count match before ordering. It's a purpose-built part for five-button hoods, not a universal catch-all for every panel style.
Final Choice by Use Case
- For a Sam's Club grill ignition issue: Go with the Modern Home Products MHP IG-17B igniter.
- For a range hood button panel that no longer responds: Choose the Range Hood Switch 5 Button.
- If you need a replacement for a traditional hood with pushbutton controls: The Range Hood Switch is built for that job.
