A refrigerator water filter is not a category where the biggest pack automatically makes the best choice. The crucial decision is matching the filter family named for your refrigerator-such as Filter 1, ICE2, Filter 2, or LG LT700P-then choosing a pack count and listed price that fit your replacement plan. These home appliances options range from $8.85 to $54.99, but they serve different compatibility groups.
Quick take
- Choose the 2 Pck Fridge Filter when your refrigerator uses the Filter 1 / EDR1RXD1 / W10295370A family and a two-filter pack is the right quantity.
- Choose the 3 Pack Whirlpool ICE2 F2WC9I1 for the ICE2 / F2WC9I1 format, especially if OEM wording and an ice-maker feature matter for your setup.
- Choose the 4 PACK EVERYDROP EDR2RXD1 when the required format is EveryDrop 2 / EDR2RXD1 and four filters suit your household.
- Choose the 6 Pack Fit for LG LT700P when your refrigerator matches LG LT700P or Kenmore 46-9690 references and you want the lowest listed price in this group.
Listed price comparison
| Filter pack | Listed price | Pack count | Compatibility cue | Price bar |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Pck Fridge Filter EDR1RXD1 | USD 26.80 | 2 | Filter 1 / W10295370A | |
| 3 Pack Whirlpool ICE2 F2WC9I1 | USD 54.99 | 3 | ICE2 / F2WC9I1 | |
| 4 PACK EVERYDROP EDR2RXD1 | USD 43.99 | 4 | EveryDrop 2 / Filter 2 | |
| 6 Pack Fit for LG LT700P | USD 8.85 | 6 | LG LT700P / Kenmore 46-9690 |
Decision matrix
Match the filter number first. The first two options are not interchangeable with the EveryDrop 2 or LG LT700P choices: their titles identify different filter families. A Filter 1 refrigerator points toward the EDR1RXD1 pack, while an ICE2 refrigerator points toward the Whirlpool F2WC9I1 pack.
Use pack count to set your replacement cadence. The choices run from a two-pack through a six-pack. The EveryDrop option sits in the middle with four filters, while the LG LT700P-compatible option offers six.
Consider listed filtration details after compatibility. The EDR1RXD1 pack identifies carbon/charcoal and coconut shell carbon filtration. The LG-compatible RedyPure pack identifies carbon/charcoal filtration, a 300-gallon filtration life, and NSF42 in its attributes. The Whirlpool ICE2 title identifies OEM and NSF Certified.
Product notes
2 Pck Fridge Filter - EDR1RXD1, W10295370A, Filter 1, 46-9081, 46-9930, KAD1RXD1
This two-pack makes sense for a refrigerator that takes Filter 1 references, including EDR1RXD1, W10295370A, 46-9081, and 46-9930. Its compatibility list is extensive, which is useful when the existing cartridge carries one of several equivalent-looking part numbers. The listed 200-gallon capacity and carbon/charcoal, coconut shell carbon filtration provide additional selection cues. Its limitation is equally clear: it is specifically centered on the Filter 1 family and contains two filters, so it is not the fit for a refrigerator calling for ICE2, EveryDrop 2, or LG LT700P.
3 Pack Whirlpool ICE2 F2WC9I1 Fridge Water Filter OEM NSF Certified New
Pick this Whirlpool three-pack when ICE2 or F2WC9I1 is the filter reference required by the refrigerator. The title identifies it as OEM and NSF Certified, while the description positions it for select Whirlpool, Maytag, KitchenAid, and JennAir refrigerators using the ICE2 format. It also lists an ice-maker feature, giving it a direct connection to refrigerators that dispense both water and ice. The main trade-off is its USD 54.99 listed price, the highest in this comparison, and its ICE2 / F2WC9I1 focus rather than Filter 1, Filter 2, or LG LT700P compatibility.
4 PACK EVERYDROP EDR2RXD1 Refrigerator Wate Filter 2 Replacement Home NEW US
The EveryDrop choice is the direct four-filter option for a refrigerator using EveryDrop 2 or EDR2RXD1, also described in its title as Filter 2. It is listed as compatible with Whirlpool and uses charcoal as its stated material. Four filters can be a practical middle ground for shoppers who want more than the two-pack EDR1RXD1 option without selecting the six-pack LG-compatible format. Its limitation is the model-specific focus: the EDR2RXD1 designation is distinct from Filter 1, ICE2, and LG LT700P references, so the model family should guide the decision before pack count.
6 Pack Fit for LG LT700P ADQ36006101 46-9690 RFC1200A Refrigerator Water Filter
This is the clearest pick for LG LT700P, ADQ36006101, ADQ36006102, and Kenmore 9690 / 46-9690 compatibility references. It combines the largest pack count here with the lowest listed price, and its attributes specify a 300-gallon, six-month filtration life. The listing also identifies carbon/charcoal filtration, chlorine taste and odor removal, and NSF42. Its key limitation is that its fit is directed to LG and Kenmore model references; it is not the choice for Whirlpool Filter 1, ICE2, or EveryDrop 2 refrigerator filter formats.
Final recommendation by use case
For a Filter 1 refrigerator, select the 2 Pck Fridge Filter EDR1RXD1 because its compatible-model list directly includes EDR1RXD1 and W10295370A. For an ICE2 / F2WC9I1 refrigerator, the 3 Pack Whirlpool ICE2 F2WC9I1 is the model-matched choice. For a refrigerator requiring EveryDrop 2 / EDR2RXD1, choose the 4 PACK EVERYDROP EDR2RXD1. For compatible LG LT700P or Kenmore 46-9690 refrigerators, the 6 Pack Fit for LG LT700P pairs six filters with the lowest listed price of the four.
