At a Glance
You need a replacement part for a home appliance, but the two candidates on your list solve completely different problems. One is an ignition component for a gas grill; the other is a glass shelf for a refrigerator. Choosing between them isn't about comparing specs side by side-it's about matching the right part to the appliance you need to fix.
Quick Verdict
If your Sam's Club grill won't light, the Modern Home Products Replacement Ignitor MHP IG-17B is the new igniter to consider. If your Electrolux or Frigidaire refrigerator needs a shelf, the Frigidaire Home Products FGHC2331PFAA Refrigerator Glass Shelf is the used clear/white shelf that matches that model. The grill part is listed at USD 15.97; the fridge shelf is listed at USD 34.98.
Comparison Table
Here's a compact look at the listed prices and key attributes:
| Product | Price | Model | Type | Condition | Price bar |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Modern Home Products Replacement Ignitor Component MHP IG-17B | USD 15.97 | Sam 's Club Member 's Mark IG17B IG-17B | Igniter | New | |
| Frigidaire Home Products FGHC2331PFAA Refrigerator Glass Shelf | USD 34.98 | FGHC2331PFAA | Refrigerator glass shelf | Used |
Where Each Product Wins
The Modern Home Products ignitor wins for grill owners who need a replacement ignition component for a Sam's Club grill with multiple cast iron or brass burners. It's a focused replacement part for that grill style. The Frigidaire Home Products glass shelf wins for refrigerator owners who need a clear/white glass shelf for the FGHC2331PFAA model. It's made for Electrolux Home Products refrigerators and matches that specific model.
Product Notes
Modern Home Products Replacement Ignitor Component MHP IG-17B - Sams Club Grills
The Modern Home Products Replacement Ignitor Component MHP IG-17B comes sealed in packaging and is intended for grills with multiple cast iron or brass burners. If your Sam's Club grill has that burner setup, this is a direct replacement ignitor to fit the ignition system. The country of origin is China. The limitation is the fit: the label says it fits many Sam's Club grills, not every grill. If your grill's burner arrangement differs or the igniter doesn't align with your model's design, this part might not be the one. It's a focused replacement component for a specific grill style.
Frigidaire Home Products FGHC2331PFAA Refrigerator Glass Shelf, Clear/White
The Frigidaire Home Products FGHC2331PFAA Refrigerator Glass Shelf is a clear/white shelf made from glass and plastic, designed for the Electrolux Home Products brand. It is compatible with the FGHC2331PFAA refrigerator model, and the set includes one glass shelf. The convenience is the direct model match: you're getting a shelf that is made to fit that specific Electrolux/Frigidaire refrigerator. The limitation is also that specificity-if your refrigerator isn't the FGHC2331PFAA, this shelf isn't designed for it. You're buying a replacement shelf, not a universal shelf, so the model match is the deciding factor.
Final Choice by Use Case
Choose the Modern Home Products Replacement Ignitor if you're fixing a Sam's Club grill with multiple cast iron or brass burners and want a replacement part. Choose the Frigidaire Home Products FGHC2331PFAA Refrigerator Glass Shelf if you own the matching Electrolux/Frigidaire refrigerator and need a replacement shelf that returns storage space to that specific model.
