A refrigerator filter replacement has one non-negotiable decision before price or pack size: it needs to match the refrigerator's filter family. The EPTWFU01 route is identified for Frigidaire, while EveryDrop EDR2RXD1 is identified for Whirlpool, making compatibility the starting point rather than an afterthought.
Quick Verdict
Choose the 6 Packs EPTWFU01 Water Filter Replacement, Compatible with Frigidaire when the refrigerator uses the EPTWFU01, EWF02, or Pure Source Ultra II family and a six-item package is appealing. Its listed price is USD 25.49.
Choose the 4 PACK ΕVΕRYDROP ΕDR2RXD1 Refrigerator Wate Filter 2 Replacement Home NEW US when EDR2RXD1 / Filter 2 is the required replacement designation for a Whirlpool refrigerator. Its listed price is USD 43.99. The listed-price spread between the two options is USD 18.50.
At-a-Glance Comparison
| Detail | EPTWFU01 Replacement | EveryDrop EDR2RXD1 Replacement |
|---|---|---|
| Listed price | USD 25.49 | USD 43.99 |
| Pack format | 6 filters | 4 filters |
| Color | White | White |
| Condition | New | New |
Where Each Filter Wins
The EPTWFU01 replacement is the better match when chlorine taste and odor removal is a stated priority. It lists a carbon/charcoal filtration method and specifically identifies chlorine taste and odor under contaminant removal.
The EveryDrop option is the focused choice for a refrigerator that calls for the EDR2RXD1 Filter 2 designation. Its title and model information use that specific replacement family, rather than the EPTWFU01 family used by the Frigidaire-compatible alternative.
Product Notes
EPTWFU01 Replacement Filter for Frigidaire
The six-filter EPTWFU01 option fits a household that wants multiple replacements in one package rather than a four-filter format. Along with its carbon/charcoal filtration method, it identifies chlorine taste and odor as its contaminant-removal focus. The main limitation is fit: it is specified for Frigidaire and names the EPTWFU01, EWF02, and Pure Source Ultra II model family. The white, new filter is made of plastic. Pick the EPTWFU01 replacement when those Frigidaire part-number cues match the refrigerator and the six-item pack format suits the household's replacement routine.
EveryDrop EDR2RXD1 Refrigerator Water Filter 2
EveryDrop EDR2RXD1 is the straightforward pick for a Whirlpool refrigerator using the Filter 2 replacement designation. The model is identified as EveryDrop 2 / EDR2RXD1, with charcoal listed as the material; it is also a new, white filter. Its limitation is the same specificity that makes it useful: the stated compatibility is for Whirlpool, not Frigidaire. The package contains four items, so it is the smaller listed pack in this comparison. Choose the EveryDrop EDR2RXD1 when the refrigerator's required filter family aligns with Whirlpool Filter 2 and charcoal material is the preferred listed format.
Final Choice by Use Case
For a Frigidaire filter family using EPTWFU01, EWF02, or Pure Source Ultra II references, the EPTWFU01 replacement is the clear match and carries the lower listed price. For a Whirlpool refrigerator requiring the EDR2RXD1 / Filter 2 family, choose the EveryDrop option. Once filter-family fit is settled, the practical tie-breaker is simple: six filters at USD 25.49 versus four filters at USD 43.99.
